Feature

Illinois becomes second state in the US to ban 'gay panic' defence

Several more states are expected to follow later this year.

Illinois becomes second US state to ban gay panic defence

Source: AP / Chicago Tribune

Starting this month Illinois becomes the second state in the U.S. to rule out the "gay panic" defence.

The defence allowed for defendants to use a victim's sexual orientation or gender identity as the justification for violent crimes committed against them.

Often the argument frames a crime in that the defendant was "provoked" after seeing queer acts or due to sexual advances from the victim. It was often used as a loophole in an attempt to downgrade homicide charges to manslaughter. 

While the defence isn't common, and those that have attempted to use it have rarely been successful, advocates for the ban believed it was imperative to introduce due to a rise in crimes against LGBT+people.

The legislation went through without opposition in the state House or Senate, being signed off by Governer Bruse Rauner in August, and coming into effect from January 1.

California was the first state to ban the defence back in 2014, with LGBT+ advocates looking to repeat the success in Illinois in half a dozen states.

Brian Johnson, CEO of Equality Illinois said, "For us, it was important to eradicate (the defence), regardless of use"

"It makes our identity sufficient reason for murder. We never wanted it to be used going forward."

Tasmania was the first Australian state to introduce reforms abolishing the defence of provocation in 2003. All other states followed, excluding South Australia which still allows the argument.

Share
Published 2 January 2018 4:26pm
By Mathew Whitehead


Share this with family and friends


SBS News in your Inbox

Sign up now for the latest news from Australia and around the world direct to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

Download our apps
SBS On Demand
SBS News
SBS Audio

Listen to our podcasts
Join host Yumi Stynes for Seen, a new SBS podcast about cultural creatives who have risen to excellence despite a role-model vacuum.
The day's top stories from SBS News.
Ease into the English language and Australian culture. We make learning English convenient, fun and practical.
Get the latest with our sbs podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch SBS On Demand
Over 11,000 hours

Over 11,000 hours

News, drama, documentaries, SBS Originals and more - free.